In my opinion the fulfillment of a criterion or a group of criteria as a whole is performed by some individual
We state "X fulfills all these eligibility criteria"
The evidences can support the statement S: "X fulfills all these eligibility criteria"
In order to support the statement the evidences must be referred to X, they must have X as subject.
In our model the subject of an evidence is missing.
And the subject that meets the criteria is missing as well.
Moreover, we state that a criterion may have a weight, but this weight is related to a group of criteria.