Navigation path

Open source observatory

(
 
)
4.69/5 | 175 votes
Editor's choice

Emilia-Romagna ends its use of OpenOffice

(
 
)
5/5 | 1 votes |
Editor's Choice

Region to switch to proprietary cloud office alternative

For the second time this year, an Italian public administration is ending its use of open source office productivity software. A source in the IT department of the Emilia-Romagna region confirmed to the Open Source Observatory last week that the region will end its use of OpenOffice. The region will move to a cloud-based proprietary office solution, others say.

The IT department has yet to respond to a request for comment sent recently. This news item will be updated as more information becomes available.

On 31 October, a press statement from the region’s councillor for the Digital Agenda, Raffaele Donini, mentioned the use of unspecified cloud solutions, which should reduce the number of pages printed by the administration each year by some 5 million. The switch would save EUR 700,000 per year.

Update: the region took its decision to switch to a cloud solution on 24 October.

Resistance

The regional administration completed its switch to Apache OpenOffice in April last year. Emilia-Romagna had made the Open Document Format ODF the default on all of its 4200 workstations, across 10 departments and 5 agencies.

Talking about the switch, in a presentation at the 2015 Fosdem conference in Brussels, IT administrators warned they could face resistance from users. To help manage the change, the IT department had readied a team of support staff.

Earlier this year, the government of Italy's South Tyrol province decided to end its use of LibreOffice. At the time, South Tyrol Councillor Waltraud Deeg, responsible for the Department for Public Administration said: ”Our decision was not a choice between open source or not - we took a strategic decision to transfer basic services to cloud, with the aim of fostering a more efficient and up-to-date way of working. We are not about to buy licenses, but a service.”

Lost chance

“This news makes us sad”, said Sonia Montegiove, president of the LibreItalia free software advocacy group, a few days ahead of the group’s annual conference. “The decision by the region for a non-standard format and proprietary cloud solution will once again lock them in to a single vendor’s software and services. This is a lost chance for freedom and openness.”

She added that LibreItalia will contact the region’s Director General to ask about the mandatory comparative study between proprietary and open source alternatives. Such a study is required by the country's Codice Amministrazione Digitale.

Comments

Abel Pardo
Posted by Abel Pardo on November 11, 2016 at 20:02
"

No, expensive one is not always the better one but there are people that think in this way.

Most of times open free solutions are better ones because after those solutions people work just for looking for a better developed world.

But this could be a long discussion.

Dylan Guibot
Posted by Dylan Guibot on November 11, 2016 at 19:48
"

Expensive one is the better one?

Paolo Dongilli
Posted by Paolo Dongilli on November 04, 2016 at 19:28
"

Dear Robert,

I personally bought both the paper and the eBook versions of "The Open Source Everything Manifesto" which I find a good work.
The fundamental aspect I really don't understand though is that if on one side you propose to open source everything, the most important document, the manifesto that describes this great vision is itself closed source (all rights reserved)!
I see this as a contradiction in terms.
Why didn't you publish it under a Creative Commons License?

Best,
Paolo.

Robert Steele
Posted by Robert Steele on November 02, 2016 at 13:12
"

I have been saying for some time (every since I wrote The Open Source Everything Manifesto) that it is not good enough to just have open source software and open source hardware, we need open source everything including open access, openBTS (base transceiver service), open cloud, open data, open spectrum, open standards. Until and unless the European Union creates an Open Source (Technologies) Agency and commit to going open everything, administrators will inevitably choose "easy expensive" over "smart inexpensive," never mind the opportunity cost to end-users and tax-payers.

Multiple free full text online papers on the need for an Open Source Ecology are available at http://tinyurl.com/Steele-Future, see particularly:

Open Source Everything Engineering (OSEE) - a Nordic Manifesto

Open Source Everything Engineering (OSEE) - Creating the Academy, Economy, Government, and Society of the Future