Advanced search
Adopt new elements in the ESPD
Add into the Criterion class required elements to allow for automatic evaluation of criteria. EvaluationTypeCode: a code specifying whether the criterion is of type fail/pass, weight in, or any other. EvaluationWeightTypeCode: a code representing possibly a percentage, a formula returning a weight…
DISCUSSIONCreated: 18/11/2016Updated Date: 18/11/2016
Improve descriptions of Use Cases
Improve the clarity of the descriptions of the different use cases in the document. The use cases have as a goal to give specific descriptions of the needs that the vocabulary will be providing solutions for. However, the use cases seem to be cases which are focused on describing how the needs are…
DISCUSSIONCreated: 18/11/2016Updated Date: 18/11/2016
Specify RDF elements
The standard could be improved by specifying the RDF elements in the vocabulary of the standard. It is not sufficient to reference the used RDF vocabulary as a whole. It is necessary to reference the specific RDF class and the specific RDF characteristics. We are going to provide an RDF version of…
DISCUSSIONCreated: 18/11/2016Updated Date: 18/11/2016
e-CERTIS as an example
in the examples we cite the ESPD as the frst example, while e-CERTIS would have been a more suited example, since the correspondence between criteria and evidences is stated in e-CERTIS. In the ESPD we find only a self declaration that a subject meets the criteria and can show some evidences. e…
DISCUSSIONCreated: 04/06/2016Updated Date: 04/06/2016
who fulfills a criterion
In my opinion the fulfillment of a criterion or a group of criteria as a whole is performed by some individual We state "X fulfills all these eligibility criteria" The evidences can support the statement S: "X fulfills all these eligibility criteria" In order to support the statement the evidences…
DISCUSSIONCreated: 04/06/2016Updated Date: 04/06/2016
new example
Not properly an issue... As noted, the Vocabulary should be simpler and flexible enough to be used outside the e-Procurement domain. The Criteria - Evidence matching is part of Decision Making processes Apart form the common Criteria framework, I have found the following example of a Decision…
DISCUSSIONCreated: 25/04/2016Updated Date: 25/04/2016
Improve example
4. the cinema example is very good because it illustrates the concepts and their complexity in a deceptively simple, effective way. However, I think there are some corrections/improvements which could be made: - remove distracting (and even misleading) details: e.g., "bought a ticket for the…
DISCUSSIONCreated: 25/04/2016Updated Date: 25/04/2016
Data model: Mapping eSENS requirements
3. other adjustments or additions to the CCCEV data model should emerge from the actual exercise of mapping all the Wp5.4 semantics from excel sheets to the model. Reported by David Mitzman and Loukia Demiri Component Code Category improvement
DISCUSSIONCreated: 25/04/2016Updated Date: 25/04/2016
Data model: Link from Legal Framework to Criterion Requirement
I have some doubts about whether the Legal framework should be linked the <criterion> or to the <CriterionRequirement> class (or both). I need to think about it more and to see more examples. Reported by David Mitzman and Loukia Demiri Component Code Category improvement
DISCUSSIONCreated: 25/04/2016Updated Date: 25/04/2016
Provide a Classification of Criterion Types
1. there is a strong need to describe a classification of criterionTypes with different levels of abstraction. Even for a single domain, but certainly for multi domains it is impossible to maintain and use a flat list of criteria. Some natural high-level attribute criterion classes for Business Life…
DISCUSSIONCreated: 25/04/2016Updated Date: 25/04/2016
Context in the requirements
In chapter 3 : R3 criterion may contain an indicator whether it is fulfillled or not: a criterion instance used in a reply form? The requirement shoudl better set the context Reported by Cécile Guasch Component Documentation Category improvement
DISCUSSIONCreated: 22/04/2016Updated Date: 22/04/2016
Should weight be in the data model?
In chapter 3 : R1 Criterion has a weighht. If it is part of a given form OK but weights can vary depending where / when/ by whom the criterion is used. Reported by Cécile Guasch Component Documentation Category feature
DISCUSSIONCreated: 22/04/2016Updated Date: 22/04/2016