{"text_format":"1","workbook":"xlsx","n_sheets":15,"sheets":["Cover","Setup_MSP","Setup_TS","Sheet1","Assessment_MSP","Setup_EIF","Setup_ODSAT","Assessment_ODSAT","Assessment_EIF","Assessment_TS","Results","ResultsTS","ResultsMSP","Results ","ResultsODSAT"],"not_rendered":{"charts":3,"images":3,"macros":1,"external_links":1,"defined_names":2,"comments":0,"pivot_tables":0},"unopened":[],"bounds":{"document_bytes":16777216,"sheet_cells":100000,"rows_first":2000,"rows_last":500,"rows_between":2000,"halvings":0,"cell_chars":16384,"cell_head_chars":4096},"cells_cut":0,"cells_raw":0,"read":"whole","date_system":"1900"}

{"sheet":"Cover","index":0,"n_rows":58,"n_cols":12,"rows_kept":58,"cut":false,"hidden":false,"merged":[[43,10,43,11],[36,1,39,10],[25,1,27,10],[29,1,32,10],[14,4,14,8],[22,1,23,10],[15,4,15,8],[6,0,6,2],[11,0,11,11],[12,0,12,11],[18,4,18,7],[19,4,19,7],[54,2,54,11],[55,2,55,11],[56,2,56,11],[57,2,57,11],[54,0,54,1],[55,0,55,1],[56,0,56,1],[57,0,57,1],[49,0,49,1],[52,0,52,1],[44,0,44,1],[53,0,53,1],[49,2,49,11],[52,2,52,11],[53,2,53,11],[50,0,50,1],[51,0,51,1],[50,2,50,11],[51,2,51,11],[45,1,45,11]]}
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,"joinup"]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[" CAMSS Solution"]
["ASSESSMENT TOOLS"]
[]
[null,null,null,null,"              Tool version: 3.1.0"]
[null,null,null,null,"              Tool Release Date: 31/03/2020"]
[]
[]
[null,null,null,null,"Select the Assessment Scenario"]
[null,null,null,null,"EIF"]
[]
[]
[null,"This CAMSS scenario is dedicated to the assesment of formal technical specification, in general terms. According to the regulation on standardisation 1025/2022, a technical specification is a \"document that prescribes technical requirements to be fulfilled by a product, process, service or system\". "]
[]
[]
[null,"This CAMSS scenario is dedicated to the assessment of  formal specifications in the context of public procurement. The criteria used are laid out in the Annex II of the regulation on standardisation 1025_2012 as requirements for the identification of ICT technical specifications for their use in procurement"]
[]
[]
[]
[null,"The European Interoperability Framework(EIF) provides guidance to public administrations on how to improve governance of their interoperability activities, establish cross-organisational relationships, streamline processes supporting end-to-end digital services, and ensure that existing and new legislation do not compromise interoperability efforts.This CAMSS Scenario allows to assess the compliance of interoperability specifications with the EIF. The objective of the obtained assessment is to determine the suitability of the assessed interoperability specification for the delivery of interoperable European public services."]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[null,"PENDING SAT TO BE PRODUCED"]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,"Send feedback"]
[]
[]
[null,null,null,null,"Technical specification"]
[null,null,null,null,"MSP"]
[null,null,null,null,"EIF"]
["►  CAMSS-18"]
["►  CAMSS-33"]
["►  CAMSS-32"]
["►  CAMSS-37"]
["►  CAMSS-40"]
["►  CAMSS-42"]
["►  CAMSS-44"]
["►  CAMSS-41"]
["►  CAMSS-49"]

{"sheet":"Setup_MSP","index":1,"n_rows":61,"n_cols":20,"rows_kept":61,"cut":false,"hidden":true,"merged":[[0,5,0,22],[1,3,1,16],[2,3,2,16],[6,3,6,5],[6,7,6,16],[8,3,8,5],[8,7,8,16],[10,3,10,5],[10,7,10,16],[12,3,12,5],[12,7,12,16],[14,3,14,5],[14,7,14,16],[16,3,16,5],[16,7,16,16],[18,3,18,5],[18,7,18,16],[22,3,22,5],[22,7,22,16],[24,3,24,5],[24,7,24,16],[26,3,26,5],[26,7,26,16],[28,3,28,5],[28,7,28,16],[52,3,52,9],[52,13,52,16],[30,3,30,5],[30,7,30,16],[32,3,32,5],[32,7,32,16],[34,3,34,5],[34,7,34,16],[54,3,54,9],[54,13,54,16],[60,0,60,16],[36,3,36,5],[36,7,36,16],[38,3,38,5],[38,7,38,16],[40,3,40,5],[40,7,40,16],[43,13,43,16],[46,3,46,9],[46,13,46,16],[58,3,58,9],[58,13,58,16],[48,3,48,9],[48,13,48,16]]}
[null,null,null,null,null,"Please, fill in the mandatory* information to  start the assessment","Please, fill in the mandatory* information to  start the asseement","Please, fill in the mandatory* information to  start the asseement","Please, fill in the mandatory* information to  start the asseement","Please, fill in the mandatory* information to  start the asseement","Please, fill in the mandatory* information to  start the asseement","Please, fill in the mandatory* information to  start the asseement","Please, fill in the mandatory* information to  start the asseement","Please, fill in the mandatory* information to  start the asseement","Please, fill in the mandatory* information to  start the asseement","Please, fill in the mandatory* information to  start the asseement","Please, fill in the mandatory* information to  start the asseement","Please, fill in the mandatory* information to  start the asseement"]
[null,null,null,"* I have read and agreed to the following CAMSS Privacy Statement: here"]
[null,null,null,"I agree to be contacted for evaluation purposes, namely to share my feedback on specific ISA2 solutions and actions and on the ISA2 programme and the European Interoperability Framework in general."]
[]
[null,null,null,"INFORMATION ON THE SUBMITTER"]
[]
[null,null,"L1","Last name, First name"]
[]
[null,null,"L2","Organisation"]
[]
[null,null,"L3","Position/ Role"]
[]
[null,null,"L4","Contact address"]
[]
[null,null,"L5","Contact phone number"]
[]
[null,null,"L6","Contact email"]
[]
[null,null,"L7","Date of submission",null,null,"*"]
[]
[null,null,null,"INFORMATION ON THE SUBMISSION"]
[]
[null,null,"P1","Title of specification",null,null,"*"]
[]
[null,null,"P2","Address where the version of the specification can be obtained",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,"MIN"]
[]
[null,null,"P3","Name, identifier and website of the standard developing/setting organisation (SDO/SSO) of the specification",null,null,"*",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,"MIN"]
[]
[null,null,"P4","Contact information/contact person \na) for the organisation\nb) for the specification submitted",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,"MIN"]
[]
[null,null,"P5","Reason for the submission, the need and intended use for the specification",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,"MIN"]
[]
[null,null,"P6","If any other evaluation of this specification is known, e.g. by member states or European Commission projects, provide a link to this evaluation.",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,"MIN"]
[]
[null,null,"P7","State whether this submission concerns:\nA) Identification of a new specification\nB) a revision of an already identified specification \nC) a proposal to withdraw the identification of an already identified specification  ",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,"MIN"]
[]
[null,null,"P8","If P.7, Case B, applies:\nplease provide information on backward and forward compatibility with the version already approved. ",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,"MIN"]
[]
[null,null,"P9","If P.7, Case C applies:\nexplain why the ICT specification  no longer complies with the requirements for identification or the reasons for its withdrawal",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,"MIN"]
[]
[null,null,"P10","The submitted ICT specification is :\nA) the first ICT specification from this standards developing organisation\nB) an ICT specification coming from a SDO of which a specification has previously been identified and which has undergone the same development and approval processes in the organisation.\n",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,"MIN"]
[]
[null,null,null,"CONSIDERATION"]
[]
[null,null,null,"          CORRECTNESS"]
[]
[null,null,"C1","The previous information in this page are correctly provided"]
[]
[null,null,"C2","The complete documentation to perform the assessement is provided"]
[]
[null,null,null,"            RELEVANCE"]
[]
[null,null,"C3","The functional area of application for the formal specification is addressing interoperabiity and eGovernment",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,"MIN"]
[]
[null,null,"C4","The formal specification meets business needs of public administrations"]
[]
[null,null,null,"            LEGISLATION AND REGULATION"]
[]
[null,null,"C5","The formal specification doesn’t hamper the regulatory requirements for its area of application",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,"MIN"]
[]
["Please, fill in the mandatory* information to  start the assessment"]

{"sheet":"Setup_TS","index":2,"n_rows":107,"n_cols":14,"rows_kept":107,"cut":false,"hidden":true,"merged":[[0,4,0,16],[1,3,1,16],[2,3,2,16],[18,3,18,5],[18,7,18,16],[12,3,12,5],[12,7,12,16],[6,3,6,5],[6,7,6,16],[8,3,8,5],[8,7,8,16],[10,3,10,5],[10,7,10,16],[20,3,20,5],[20,7,20,16],[14,3,14,5],[14,7,14,16],[16,3,16,5],[16,7,16,16],[26,7,26,16],[28,3,28,5],[32,3,32,5],[32,7,32,16],[22,3,22,5],[22,7,22,16],[24,3,24,5],[24,7,24,16],[106,1,106,17],[26,3,26,5],[36,3,36,5],[36,7,36,16],[38,3,38,5],[38,7,38,16],[28,7,28,16],[30,3,30,5],[30,7,30,16],[40,3,40,5],[40,7,40,16],[42,3,42,5],[42,7,42,16],[44,3,44,5],[44,7,44,16],[46,3,46,5],[46,7,46,16],[48,3,48,5],[48,7,48,16],[50,3,50,5],[50,7,50,16],[52,3,52,5],[52,7,52,16],[54,3,54,5],[54,7,54,16],[56,3,56,5],[56,7,56,16],[58,3,58,5],[58,7,58,16],[60,3,60,5],[60,7,60,16],[62,3,62,5],[62,7,62,16],[64,3,64,5],[64,7,64,16],[66,3,66,5],[66,7,66,16],[68,3,68,5],[68,7,68,16],[78,3,78,5],[78,7,78,16],[80,3,80,5],[80,7,80,16],[70,3,70,5],[70,7,70,16],[72,3,72,5],[72,7,72,16],[74,3,74,5],[74,7,74,16],[76,3,76,5],[76,7,76,16],[98,3,98,9],[102,3,102,9],[104,3,104,9],[82,3,82,5],[82,7,82,16],[84,3,84,5],[84,7,84,16],[96,3,96,9],[86,3,86,5],[86,7,86,16],[88,3,88,5],[88,7,88,16],[94,3,94,9]]}
[null,null,null,null,"Please, fill in the mandatory* information to  start the assessment"]
[null,null,"✓","*I have read and agreed to the following CAMSS Privacy Statement: here"]
[null,null,"X","I agree to be contacted for evaluation purposes, namely to share my feedback on specific ISA2 solutions and actions and on the ISA2 programme and the European Interoperability Framework in general."]
[]
[null,null,null,"INFORMATION ON THE SUBMITTER"]
[]
[null,null,"L1","Name, First name"]
[]
[null,null,"L2","Organisation"]
[]
[null,null,"L3","Position / Role"]
[]
[null,null,"L4","Contact address"]
[]
[null,null,"L5","Contact phone number"]
[]
[null,null,"L6","Contact email"]
[]
[null,null,"L7","Date of submission",null,null,"*"]
[]
[null,null,"L8","Scenario for assessment",null,null,"*"]
[]
[null,null,"L9","Public administration"]
[]
[null,null,"L10","Alternatives considered"]
[]
[null,null,"L11","Process approach"]
[]
[null,null,"L12","Members of Assessment panel "]
[]
[null,null,"L13","Consultation and validation roles"]
[]
[null,null,"L14","Members of decision making body"]
[]
[null,null,null,"INFORMATION ON THE SUBMISSION"]
[]
[null,null,"P1","Title of specification",null,null,"*"]
[]
[null,null,"P2","Address where the version of the specification can be obtained"]
[]
[null,null,"P3","Name and website of the standard developing/setting organisation (SDO/SSO) of the specification",null,null,"*"]
[]
[null,null,"P4","Contact information/contact person \na) for the organisation\nb) for the specification submitted"]
[]
[null,null,"P5","Reason for the submission, the need and intended use for the specification"]
[]
[null,null,"P6","If any other evaluation of this specification is known, e.g. by member states or European Commission projects, provide a link to this evaluation."]
[]
[null,null,"P7","State whether this submission concerns:\nA) Identification of a new specification\nB) a revision of an already identified specification \nC) a proposal to withdraw the identification of an already identified specification  "]
[]
[null,null,"P8","If P.7, Case B, applies:\nplease provide information on backward and forward compatibility with the version already approved. "]
[]
[null,null,"P9","If P.7, Case C applies:\nexplain why the ICT specification  no longer complies with the requirements for identification or the reasons for its withdrawal"]
[]
[null,null,"P10","The submitted ICT specification is :\nA) the first ICT specification from this standards developing organisation\nB) an ICT specification coming from a SDO of which a specification has previously been identified and which has undergone the same development and approval processes in the organisation."]
[]
[null,null,"P11","Date of creation"]
[]
[null,null,"P12","Date of last modification"]
[]
[null,null,"P13","Description"]
[]
[null,null,"P14","ID"]
[]
[null,null,"P15","Keywords"]
[]
[null,null,"P16","Asset type"]
[]
[null,null,"P17","Current version"]
[]
[null,null,"P18","Documentation"]
[]
[null,null,"P19","Domain"]
[]
[null,null,"P20","Interoperability level"]
[]
[null,null,"P21","Language"]
[]
[null,null,"P22","Previous version"]
[]
[null,null,"P23","Release"]
[]
[null,null,"P24","Spatial coverage"]
[]
[null,null,"P25","Subject"]
[]
[null,null,"P26","Status"]
[]
[null,null,"P27","Business need(s)/requirements"]
[]
[null,null,null,"CONSIDERATION"]
[null,null,"Nr","Criterion",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,"Answer",null,"Justification"]
[null,null,null,"          CORRECTNESS"]
[]
[null,null,"C1","The previous information in this page are correctly provided"]
[]
[null,null,"C2","The complete documentation to perform the assessement is provided"]
[]
[null,null,"C3","The functional area of application for the formal specification is adressing interoperabiity and eGovernment"]
[]
[null,null,null,"           LEGISLATION AND REGULATION"]
[]
[null,null,"C4","The formal specification meets the business needs of public administration"]
[]
[null,null,"C5","The formal specification doesn’t hamper the regulatory requirements for its area of application"]
[]
[null,"Please, fill in the mandatory*information to start the asseement"]

{"sheet":"Sheet1","index":3,"n_rows":0,"n_cols":0,"rows_kept":0,"cut":false,"hidden":true,"merged":[]}

{"sheet":"Assessment_MSP","index":4,"n_rows":84,"n_cols":14,"rows_kept":84,"cut":false,"hidden":true,"merged":[[75,4,75,6],[77,4,77,6],[81,4,81,6],[83,0,83,11],[55,4,55,6],[59,4,59,6],[63,4,63,6],[65,4,65,6],[69,4,69,6],[71,4,71,6],[49,4,49,6],[17,4,17,6],[19,4,19,6],[23,4,23,6],[25,4,25,6],[27,4,27,6],[29,4,29,6],[33,4,33,6],[37,4,37,6],[41,4,41,6],[45,4,45,6],[47,4,47,6],[15,4,15,6],[1,8,1,9],[3,8,3,9],[7,8,7,9],[9,8,9,9],[11,2,11,10]]}
[]
[null,null,null,null,"Date of the Assessment",null,"f"]
[]
[null,null,null,null,"SDO/SSO",null,"W3C (http://www.w3.org)"]
[]
[]
[]
[null,null,null,null,"Technical specification",null,"f"]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[null,null,"ID",null,"Criterion",null,null,null,"Answer",null,"Justification"]
[null,null,null,null," MARKET ACCEPTANCE"]
[]
[null,null,"A1",null,"Has the specification been used for different implementations by different vendors/suppliers? "]
[]
[null,null,"A2",null,"Does the implementation of the specification hamper interoperability with the implementation of existing European or international standards? ",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,"MIN"]
[]
[null,null,"A3",null,"Are you aware of public references of the respective specification by public authorities (especially policies or in procurements) ?",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,"MIN"]
[]
[null,null,null,null," COHERENCE PRINCIPLE"]
[]
[null,null,"A4",null,"Does the technical specification or standard cover areas different from areas addressed by technical specifications being under consideration to become a European standard? \n(i.e. technical specifications provided by a non-formal standardisation organisation, that is other than CEN, CENELEC or ETSI can be under consideration to become a European standard or alternatively an identified technical specification)",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,"MIN"]
[]
[null,null,"A5","a.","Is the adoption of new European Standards which cover the same areas as the proposed specification (or standard) foreseen within a reasonable timeframe? ",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,"MIN"]
[]
[null,null,null,"b.","Are there existing European standards with market uptake which cover the same areas as the proposed specification (or standard) being assessed?",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,"MIN"]
[]
[null,null,null,"c.","If yes, are the existing standards becoming obsolete?"]
[]
[null,null,null,null," ATTRIBUTES"]
[]
[null,null,"A6",null,"Is the standards developing organisation a non-profit making organisation? "]
[]
[null,null,null,null,"                    OPENNESS"]
[]
[null,null,"A7",null,"Is participation in the creation process of the specification open to all interested parties (e.g. organisations, companies or individuals)?",null,null,null,null,null,"http://www.w3.org/participate/",null,null,"MIN"]
[]
[null,null,null,null,"                    CONSENSUS"]
[]
[null,null,"A8",null,"Are the specifications approved in a decision making process which aims at reaching consensus?",null,null,null,null,null,"http://www.w3.org/Consortium/Process/#Consensus"]
[]
[null,null,null,null,"                    TRANSPARENCY"]
[]
[null,null,"A9",null,"Is relevant documentation of the development and approval process of the specification archived and identified?",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,"MIN"]
[]
[null,null,"A10",null,"Is information on (new) standardisation activities widely announced through suitable and accessible means?",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,"MIN"]
[]
[null,null,"A11",null,"All relevant stakeholders can formally appeal or raise objections to the development and approval of specifications?  ",null,null,null,null,null,"http://www.w3.org/Consortium/Process#ReviewAppeal"]
[]
[null,null,null,null," REQUIREMENTS"]
[]
[null,null,null,null,"                    MAINTENANCE"]
[]
[null,null,"A12",null,"Does the specification have a defined maintenance and support process?"]
[]
[null,null,null,null,"                    AVAILABILITY"]
[]
[null,null,"A13",null,"Is the specification publicly available for implementation and use on reasonable terms?"]
[]
[null,null,null,null,"                    INTELECTUAL PROPERTY"]
[]
[null,null,"A14","a.","Is the specification licensed on a (F)RAND basis?"]
[]
[null,null,null,"b.","Is the specification licensed on a royalty-free basis?"]
[]
[null,null,null,null,"                    RELEVANCE"]
[]
[null,null,"A15","a.","Does the  specification address and facilitate interoperability between public administrations?"]
[]
[null,null,null,"b.","Is there evidence that the adoption of the specification positively impacts one or several of the following: organisational processes; the environment; the administrative burden; the disability support; cross-border services, public policy objectives and societal needs ?",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,"MIN"]
[]
[null,null,null,null,"                    NEUTRALITY AND STABILITY"]
[]
[null,null,"A16","a.","Is the specification largely independent from specific vendor products?"]
[]
[null,null,null,"b.","Is the specification largely independent from specific platforms or technologies?"]
[]
[null,null,null,null,"                    QUALITY"]
[]
[null,null,"A17",null,"Has the specification sufficient detail, consistency and completeness for the use and development of products and services?",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,"MIN"]
[]
["                             Please respond to all the criteria before viewing the Results "]

{"sheet":"Setup_EIF","index":5,"n_rows":102,"n_cols":20,"rows_kept":102,"cut":false,"hidden":false,"merged":[[10,3,10,5],[10,7,10,16],[6,3,6,5],[6,7,6,16],[8,3,8,5],[8,7,8,16],[12,3,12,5],[12,7,12,16],[14,3,14,5],[14,7,14,16],[16,3,16,5],[16,7,16,16],[18,3,18,5],[18,7,18,16],[20,3,20,5],[20,7,20,16],[22,3,22,5],[22,7,22,16],[24,3,24,5],[24,7,24,16],[26,3,26,5],[26,7,26,16],[28,3,28,5],[28,7,28,16],[30,3,30,5],[30,7,30,16],[32,3,32,5],[32,7,32,16],[36,3,36,5],[36,7,36,16],[38,3,38,5],[38,7,38,16],[40,3,40,5],[40,7,40,16],[42,3,42,5],[42,7,42,16],[44,3,44,5],[44,7,44,16],[46,3,46,5],[46,7,46,16],[48,3,48,5],[48,7,48,16],[50,3,50,5],[50,7,50,16],[52,3,52,5],[52,7,52,16],[54,3,54,5],[54,7,54,16],[56,3,56,5],[56,7,56,16],[58,3,58,5],[58,7,58,16],[60,3,60,5],[60,7,60,16],[62,3,62,5],[62,7,62,16],[64,3,64,5],[64,7,64,16],[66,3,66,5],[66,7,66,16],[68,3,68,5],[68,7,68,16],[70,3,70,5],[70,7,70,16],[72,3,72,5],[72,7,72,16],[74,3,74,5],[74,7,74,16],[76,3,76,5],[76,7,76,16],[78,3,78,5],[78,7,78,16],[80,3,80,5],[80,7,80,16],[82,3,82,5],[82,7,82,16],[84,3,84,5],[84,7,84,16],[98,3,98,9],[101,1,101,17],[86,3,86,5],[86,7,86,16],[88,3,88,5],[88,7,88,16],[94,3,94,9],[96,3,96,9],[0,1,0,16383],[3,1,3,17],[1,1,2,1],[2,3,2,16],[1,3,1,16]]}
[null,"Please, fill in the mandatory* information to  start the assessment"]
[null,null,"X","* I have read and agreed to the following CAMSS Privacy Statement: LINK."]
[null,null,"✓","I agree to be contacted for evaluation purposes, namely to share my feedback on specific ISA2 solutions and actions and on the ISA2 programme and the European Interoperability Framework in general."]
[]
[null,null,null,"INFORMATION ON THE SUBMITTER"]
[]
[null,null,"L1","Last name, First name",null,null,null,"CAMSS Team"]
[]
[null,null,"L2","Organisation",null,null,null,"everis"]
[]
[null,null,"L3","Position / Role"]
[]
[null,null,"L4","Contact address"]
[]
[null,null,"L5","Contact phone number"]
[]
[null,null,"L6","Contact email",null,null,null,"CAMSS@everis.com"]
[]
[null,null,"L7","Date of submission",null,null,"*","2020-08-31"]
[]
[null,null,"L8","Scenario for assessment",null,null,"*","European Interoperability Framework (EIF)"]
[]
[null,null,"L9","Public administration"]
[]
[null,null,"L10","Alternatives considered"]
[]
[null,null,"L11","Process approach"]
[]
[null,null,"L12","Members of Assessment panel "]
[]
[null,null,"L13","Consultation and validation roles"]
[]
[null,null,"L14","Members of decision making body"]
[]
[null,null,null,"INFORMATION ON THE SUBMISSION",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,"."]
[]
[null,null,"P1","Title of specification",null,null,"*","Portable Document Format/A (PDF/A)"]
[]
[null,null,"P2","Address where the version of the specification can be obtained",null,null,null,"https://www.iso.org/standard/38920.html\nhttps://www.iso.org/standard/50655.html",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,"MIN"]
[]
[null,null,"P3","Name and website of the standard developing/setting organisation (SDO/SSO) of the specification",null,null,"*","Other SDO/SSO",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,"MIN"]
[]
[null,null,"P4","Contact information/contact person \na) for the organisation\nb) for the specification submitted",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,"MIN"]
[]
[null,null,"P5","Reason for the submission, the need and intended use for the specification",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,"MIN"]
[]
[null,null,"P6","If any other evaluation of this specification is known, e.g. by member states or European Commission projects, provide a link to this evaluation.",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,"MIN"]
[]
[null,null,"P7","State whether this submission concerns:\nA) Identification of a new specification\nB) a revision of an already identified specification \nC) a proposal to withdraw the identification of an already identified specification  ",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,"MIN"]
[]
[null,null,"P8","If P.7, Case B, applies:\nplease provide information on backward and forward compatibility with the version already approved. ",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,"MIN"]
[]
[null,null,"P9","If P.7, Case C applies:\nexplain why the ICT specification  no longer complies with the requirements for identification or the reasons for its withdrawal",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,"MIN"]
[]
[null,null,"P10","The submitted ICT specification is :\nA) the first ICT specification from this standards developing organisation\nB) an ICT specification coming from a SDO of which a specification has previously been identified and which has undergone the same development and approval processes in the organisation.",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,"MIN"]
[]
[null,null,"P11","Date of creation"]
[]
[null,null,"P12","Date of last modification"]
[]
[null,null,"P13","Description"]
[]
[null,null,"P14","ID"]
[]
[null,null,"P15","Keyword"]
[]
[null,null,"P16","Asset type"]
[]
[null,null,"P17","Current version"]
[]
[null,null,"P18","Documentation"]
[]
[null,null,"P19","Domain"]
[]
[null,null,"P20","Interoperability level"]
[]
[null,null,"P21","Language"]
[]
[null,null,"P22","Previous version"]
[]
[null,null,"P23","Release"]
[]
[null,null,"P24","Spatial coverage"]
[]
[null,null,"P25","Subject"]
[]
[null,null,"P26","Status"]
[]
[null,null,"P27","Business need(s)/requirements"]
[]
[null,null,null,"CONSIDERATION"]
[null,null,"ID","Criterion",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,"Answer",null,"Justification",null,null,"Justification"]
[null,null,null,"          CORRECTNESS"]
[]
[null,null,"C1","The previous information in this page are correctly provided"]
[]
[null,null,"C2","The complete documentation to perform the assessement is provided"]
[]
[null,null,"C3","The functional area of application for the formal specification is addressing interoperability and eGovernment",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,"MIN"]
[]
[]
[null,"Please, fill in the mandatory*information to start the assessment"]

{"sheet":"Setup_ODSAT","index":6,"n_rows":0,"n_cols":0,"rows_kept":0,"cut":false,"hidden":true,"merged":[]}

{"sheet":"Assessment_ODSAT","index":7,"n_rows":0,"n_cols":0,"rows_kept":0,"cut":false,"hidden":true,"merged":[]}

{"sheet":"Assessment_EIF","index":8,"n_rows":173,"n_cols":12,"rows_kept":173,"cut":false,"hidden":false,"merged":[[105,2,105,4],[107,2,107,4],[109,2,109,4],[111,2,111,4],[142,0,142,9],[113,2,113,4],[121,2,121,4],[128,2,128,4],[130,2,130,4],[117,2,117,4],[134,2,134,4],[136,2,136,4],[140,1,140,8],[23,2,23,4],[97,2,97,4],[103,2,103,4],[93,2,93,4],[55,2,55,4],[59,2,59,4],[61,2,61,4],[63,2,63,4],[65,2,65,4],[71,2,71,4],[35,2,35,4],[39,2,39,4],[41,2,41,4],[45,2,45,4],[49,2,49,4],[53,2,53,4],[95,2,95,4],[25,2,25,4],[27,2,27,4],[29,2,29,4],[31,2,31,4],[33,2,33,4],[75,2,75,4],[79,2,79,4],[83,2,83,4],[85,1,85,9],[89,2,89,4],[57,2,57,4],[37,2,37,4],[47,2,47,4],[17,2,17,4],[1,4,1,7],[3,4,3,7],[5,4,5,7],[7,4,7,7],[9,4,9,7],[13,2,13,4]]}
[]
[null,null,"Date of the Assessment",null,"2020-08-31"]
[]
[null,null,"SDO/SSO"]
[]
[]
[]
[null,null,"Interoperability specification",null,"Portable Document Format/A (PDF/A)"]
[]
[null,null,"Interoperability specification type",null,"International Standard"]
[]
[null,"ID","Criterion",null,null,null,"Answer",null,"Justification"]
[]
[null,null,"  PRINCIPLES SETTING THE CONTEXT FOR EU ACTIONS ON INTEROPERABILITY"]
[]
[null,null,"          SUBSIDIARITY AND PROPORTIONALITY"]
[]
[null,"A1","The specification has been included in a national catalogue from a Member State whose NIF is fully aligned with at least 4 out of 5 sections of the EIF according to NIFO factsheets.",null,null,null,"✓",null,"PDF/A is included in 3 national catalogues of recommended specifications. They belong to Estonia, Spain and Sweden. The National Interoperability Framework (NIF) of these Member States is fully aligned with at least 4 out of 5 sections of the European Interoperability Framework (EIF) according to the National Interoperability Framework Observatory (NIFO) factsheets. \n\nNational catalogue Estonia: \nhttps://www.mkm.ee/sites/default/files/interoperability-framework_2011.doc\n\nNational catalogue Spain:\nhttps://administracionelectronica.gob.es/pae_Home/pae_Estrategias/pae_Interoperabilidad_Inicio/pae_Normas_tecnicas_de_interoperabilidad.html#CATALOGOESTANDARES\n\nNational catalogue Sweden:\nhttps://www.avropa.se/globalassets/dokument/open-it-standards.pdf?_t_id=1B2M2Y8AsgTpgAmY7PhCfg%3d%3d&_t_q=standards&_t_tags=language%3asv%2csiteid%3a95d515a5-23ca-47bf-87a9-07b10d8ac360&_t_ip=178.139.72.144&_t_hit.id=Avropa_Core_Models_Media_GenericMedia/_ff07d720-f793-44b0-994d-27e79b28f6bd&_t_hit.pos=7\n\nNIFO factsheets:\nhttps://joinup.ec.europa.eu/collection/national-interoperability-framework-observatory-nifo/nifo-factsheets",null,null,"MIN"]
[]
[null,null,"  CORE INTEROPERABILITY PRINCIPLES"]
[]
[null,null,"          OPENNESS"]
[]
[null,"A2","The specification facilitates the publication of public data as open data.",null,null,null,"✓",null,"As a document format, PDF/A helps to make data available on the internet. This fact demonstrates that the standard is supporting the first level of maturity from Tim Berners-Lee's 5-star schema for Open data.  \n\nPDF/A reference:\nhttps://www.iso.org/standard/38920.html\nhttps://www.iso.org/standard/50655.html\n\nTim Berners-Lee 5-star schema for Open Data:   \nhttps://5stardata.info/es/ "]
[]
[null,"A3","All stakeholders have the opportunity to contribute to the development of the specification ",null,null,null,"✓",null,"ISO has defined a clear procedure to develop its standards. It consists in a 6-steps process where everyone who is interested can participate. However, if you want to participate, you have to contact your national standards body and you have to be approved for joining the Technical committee (TC) who will develop the standard. ISO has defined the roadmap of standards, it is composed of 6 steps as before said. For the approval of a standard the two-thirds majority of P-members of TC is needed. If the result is negative, the document is returned to TC/SC to be further studied.\n\nThe ISO standardization process: \nhttps://www.iso.org/stages-and-resources-for-standards-development.html",null,null,"MIN"]
[]
[null,"A4","A public review is part of the decision-making process.",null,null,null,"X",null,"As defined on the TC standardisation, only TC members are involved in the development of ISO standards. A review is carried out to arrange the consensus firstly within the TC members and subsequently is reviewed by the different ISO member bodies. However, it cannot be considered a public review, because only TC members can participate.\n\nThe ISO standardization process: \nhttps://www.iso.org/stages-and-resources-for-standards-development.html"]
[]
[null,"A5","The specification is available for everyone to study.",null,null,null,"X",null,"The ISO 19005-1:2005 and ISO 19005-2:2011 which refer to PDF/A-1 and PDF/A-2 are not available for free for everyone to study. Payment is needed to reach access to the standard.\n\nPDF/A reference:\nhttps://www.iso.org/standard/38920.html\nhttps://www.iso.org/standard/50655.html"]
[]
[null,"A6","The specification is licensed on a (F)RAND basis",null,null,null,"X",null,"There are no disclosures of ISO IPR Database to identify the licensing under the specification. ISO 19005-1:2005 (PDF/A-1) and ISO 19005-2:2011 (PDF/A-2) are not listed in ISO/IEC/ITU Common Patent policy, so it cannot be confirmed that the specification is licensed on a (F)RAND basis.\n\nISO patents:\nhttps://www.iso.org/iso-standards-and-patents.html \n\nISO standards and patents IPR database:\nhttp://isotc.iso.org/livelink/livelink/13622347/Patents_database.xls?func=doc.Fetch&nodeId=13622347 "]
[]
[null,"A7","The specification is licensed on a royalty-free basis",null,null,null,"X",null,"There are no disclosures of ISO IPR Database to identify the licensing under the specification. ISO 19005-1:2005 (PDF/A-1) and ISO 19005-2:2011 (PDF/A-2) are not listed in ISO/IEC/ITU Common Patent policy, so it cannot be confirmed that the specification is licensed on a (F)RAND basis.\n\nISO patents:\nhttps://www.iso.org/iso-standards-and-patents.html \n\nISO standards and patents IPR database:\nhttp://isotc.iso.org/livelink/livelink/13622347/Patents_database.xls?func=doc.Fetch&nodeId=13622347 "]
[]
[null,"A8","The specification is sufficiently mature for its use in the development of products and services.",null,null,null,"✓",null,"The ISO specifications are published to be able to respond to a market need which represent a consensus of an expert group. In 2005 PDF/A was published which specifies how to use the Portable Document Format (PDF) 1.4 for long-term preservation of electronic documents. These facts demonstrate the maturity and market acceptance for its use in the development of products and services. \n\nPDF/A reference:\nhttps://www.iso.org/standard/38920.html\nhttps://www.iso.org/standard/50655.html",null,null,"MIN"]
[]
[null,"A9","The specification has sufficient market acceptance for its use in the development of products and services.",null,null,null,"✓",null,"PDF/A is highly adopted as a document format for exchange information, which is technological independent. These facts demonstrate the maturity and market acceptance for its use in the development of products and services. \n\nPDF/A reference:\nhttps://www.iso.org/standard/38920.html\nhttps://www.iso.org/standard/50655.html"]
[]
[null,"A10","The specification fosters the creation of innovative solutions.",null,null,null,"X",null,"At the moment of performing the assessment, PDF/A is widely used in across sector manner. One of the main document format used for the document exchange between different parties, and to ensure the availability of documents' content over the time. A clear example of this are public administrations and the high usage of PDF as a document format to exchange information. However, it cannot be considered as an asset to build innovative solutions. \n\nPDF/A reference:\nhttps://www.iso.org/standard/38920.html\nhttps://www.iso.org/standard/50655.html"]
[]
[null,"A11","The specification has a strong support from at least one developer community.",null,null,null,"✓",null,"PDF/A has the ISO community that supports the development of: International standards, Technical Specifications, Technical Report and Publicly Available Specification.\n\nThe ISO standardization process:\nhttp://www.isotc292online.org/projects/iso-process/"]
[]
[null,null,"          TRANSPARENCY"]
[]
[null,"A12","The specification fosters the visibility of administrative rules, data, services and decision-making of a public administration.",null,null,null,"✓",null,"As a document exchange format, PDF/A is a valuable tool for sharing information through the internet. Allowing sharing data and information the standard foster the visibility of administration data and services. Additionally, it eases the decision-making process within administrations. \n\nPDF/A reference:\nhttps://www.iso.org/standard/38920.html\nhttps://www.iso.org/standard/50655.html",null,null,"MIN"]
[]
[null,"A13","The specification fosters the comprehensibility of administrative rules, data, services and decision-making of a public administration.",null,null,null,"✓",null,"As a document exchange format, PDF/A is a valuable tool for sharing information through the internet. Allowing sharing data and information the standard foster the comprehensibility of administration data and services. Additionally, it eases the decision-making process within administrations. \n\nPDF/A reference:\nhttps://www.iso.org/standard/38920.html\nhttps://www.iso.org/standard/50655.html"]
[]
[null,"A14","The specification helps to ensure the availability of interfaces with internal information systems of a public administration.",null,null,null,"N/A",null,"The purpose of PDF/A is not related to the availability of interfaces with internal information systems. Therefore, this criterion is not applicable to this specification. \n\nPDF/A reference:\nhttps://www.iso.org/standard/38920.html\nhttps://www.iso.org/standard/50655.html",null,null,"MIN"]
[]
[null,null,"          REUSABILITY"]
[]
[null,"A15","The specification is reusable beyond the domain for which it was originally developed. ",null,null,null,"✓",null,"PDF/A is a business agnostic document format that can be reused in a cross-domain way.",null,null,"MIN"]
[]
[null,"A16","The specification has been made available for its reuse by the organisations, administrations, open communities, etc. that developed it.",null,null,null,"X",null,"PDF/A is an ISO standard and as all ISO standards, they have to be paid to access its content.  \n\nPDF/A reference:\nhttps://www.iso.org/standard/38920.html\nhttps://www.iso.org/standard/50655.html",null,null,"MIN"]
[]
[null,"A17","The specification is available for free on at least one national or European platform.",null,null,null,"X",null,"There is no national or European platform with the specification PDF/A available for free. "]
[]
[null,null,"          TECHNOLOGICAL NEUTRALITY AND DATA PORTABILITY"]
[]
[null,"A18","The specification is independent of any specific technology and/or platform.",null,null,null,"✓",null,"The main objective of the Portable Document Format/A (PDF/A) is to allow text format and images to be independent and work for any software, hardware or operating system. So it can be said that PDF/A is independent of any specific technology or platform."]
[]
[null,"A19","The specification is proportionate to the needs of its users (citizens, businesses or administrations).",null,null,null,"✓",null,"The adoption of PDF/A as a document format for exchanging information does not hamper the scalability of systems. It is a widely adopted and used for this purpose and, moreover, it is independent of any platform or software. Therefore, PDF/A is proportionate to the users' needs and at the same time, it does not hamper the interoperability and scalability of systems.  ",null,null,"MIN"]
[]
[null,"A20","The specification fosters data portability between systems and applications supporting the implementation and evolution of European public services when legally possible.",null,null,null,"✓",null,"The main objective of the Portable Document Format/A (PDF/A) is to allow text format and images to be independent and work for any software, hardware, or operating system while transferring. Additionally, PDF/A is widely used by administrations to share their information and data. Fostering the availability of data and information, it fosters the data portability using documents. Moreover, the PDF/A includes features that impact positively the preservation of the information contained in this format. It is an extended method to ensure the availability of digital information over time.",null,null,"MIN"]
[]
[null,null,"PRINCIPLES RELATED TO GENERIC USER NEEDS AND EXPECTATIONS"]
[]
[null,null,"          USER-CENTRICITY"]
[]
[null,"A21","The specification eases the implementation of the once-only principle.",null,null,null,"N/A",null,"The purpose of PDF/A is not related to the implementation of the once-only principle. Therefore, this criterion does not apply to this specification. \n\nPDF/A reference:\nhttps://www.iso.org/standard/38920.html\nhttps://www.iso.org/standard/50655.html"]
[]
[null,null,"          INCLUSION AND ACCESSIBILITY"]
[]
[null,"A22","The specification fosters e-accessibility.",null,null,null,"N/A",null,"The purpose of PDF/A is not related to e-accessibility. Therefore, this criterion is considered not applicable to this specification.\n\nPDF/A reference:\nhttps://www.iso.org/standard/38920.html\nhttps://www.iso.org/standard/50655.html"]
[]
[null,null,"          SECURITY AND PRIVACY"]
[]
[null,"A23","The specification fosters the secure and trustworthy data exchange between citizens and businesses, and public administrations.",null,null,null,"✓",null,"The standard provides security features that foster the trustworthy data exchange between administration and stakeholders. PDF/A protects in itself data integrity, but also provides capabilities to protect with passwords and user roles the access to the document. \n\nPDF/A reference:\nhttps://www.iso.org/standard/38920.html\nhttps://www.iso.org/standard/50655.html",null,null,"MIN"]
[]
[null,null,"          MULTILINGUALISM"]
[]
[null,"A24","The specification fosters the delivery of multilingual European public services.",null,null,null,"N/A",null,"The purpose of PDF/A is not related to the delivery of multilingual public services. Therefore, this criterion is not applicable to this specification. \n\nPDF/A reference:\nhttps://www.iso.org/standard/38920.html\nhttps://www.iso.org/standard/50655.html"]
[]
[null,"  FOUNDATION PRINCIPLES FOR COOPERATION AMONG PUBLIC ADMINISTRATIONS"]
[]
[null,null,"          ADMINISTRATIVE SIMPLIFICATION"]
[]
[null,"A25","The adoption of the specification reduces the administrative burden.",null,null,null,"✓",null,"By allowing the exchange of digital documents, PDF/A avoids sharing non-digital documents and then helps to the reduction of administrative burden. Additionally, as a format fostering the preservation of digital information, ensures the possible reuse and exchange of data over time. \n\nPDF/A reference:\nhttps://www.iso.org/standard/38920.html\nhttps://www.iso.org/standard/50655.html",null,null,"MIN"]
[]
[null,null,"          PRESERVATION OF INFORMATION"]
[]
[null,"A26","The specification fosters the long-term preservation of electronic records and other kinds of information.",null,null,null,"✓",null,"PDF/A is designed for this purpose. It is an Electronic document file format for long-term preservation of data.\n\nPDF/A reference:\nhttps://www.iso.org/standard/38920.html\nhttps://www.iso.org/standard/50655.html",null,null,"MIN"]
[]
[null,null,"          ASSESSMENT OF EFFECTIVENESS AND EFFICIENCY"]
[]
[null,"A27","There are already existing studies or documentation assessing the specification in terms of effectiveness and efficiency.",null,null,null,"X",null,"After carrying out information retrieval, no document or study has been found assessing the PDF/A in terms of efficiency or effectiveness.",null,null,"MIN"]
[]
[null,null,"INTEROPERABILITY LAYERS"]
[]
[null,null,"           INTEROPERABILITY GOVERNANCE"]
[]
[null,"A28","The specification can be mapped to the European Interoperability Reference Architecture (EIRA).",null,null,null,"✓",null,"PDF/A is already associated with EIRA ABBs in the European Library Of Specifications (ELIS). More specifically, PDF/A can define the interoperability aspects of the \"e-Archiving Component\" and \"e-Archiving Service\" ABBs of the EIRA Technical Infrastructure View.\n\nEIRA Library of Interoperability Specifications (ELIS):\nhttps://joinup.ec.europa.eu/solution/elis/release/v100"]
[]
[null,"A29","Mechanisms to assess conformity of the implementations of the specification (e.g. conformity tests, certifications) are available for free.",null,null,null,"✓",null,"PDF-Tools provides a conformance validation for PDF and its extensions, including PDF/A. There are for free and under payment. \n\nPDF/A validators:\nhttps://www.pdf-online.com/osa/validate.aspx\nhttps://www.pdf-tools.com/pdf20/en/products/pdf-converter-validation/pdf-validator",null,null,"MIN"]
[]
[null,"A30","The specification is recommended by an EU Member State.",null,null,null,"✓",null,"5 Member States are recommending PDF/A in their ICT National Catalogues. This Member States are Estonia, Germany, Spain, Sweden and UK.\n\nCAMSS List of Standards:\nhttps://joinup.ec.europa.eu/collection/common-assessment-method-standards-and-specifications-camss/camss-list-standards"]
[]
[null,"A31","The specification has been selected for its use in an EU cross-border project or initiative after agreed identification and assessment.",null,null,null,"X",null,"After searching in the different official European websites, there is no evidence of any cross-border project that use PDF/A nor explicit agreements involving the usage of the specification.",null,null,"MIN"]
[]
[null,"A32","The specification is included in a catalogue of standards at national level.",null,null,null,"✓",null,"The specification is included in 5 Member States' catalogues of recommended specifications. These Member States are Estonia, Germany, Spain, Sweden and UK.\n\nCAMSS List of Standards:\nhttps://joinup.ec.europa.eu/collection/common-assessment-method-standards-and-specifications-camss/camss-list-standards"]
[]
[null,"A33","The specification is included in a catalogue of standards at EU level.",null,null,null,"X",null,"After checking the different standard catalogues at supra-national level, there is no evidence of the inclusion of PDF/A within any European catalogue of standards.\n\nICT technical specifications:\nhttps://ec.europa.eu/growth/industry/policy/ict-standardisation/ict-technical-specifications_en \n\nCEN search tool catalogue:\nhttps://standards.cen.eu/dyn/www/f?p=CENWEB:105::RESET::::\n\nCENELEC search tool catalogue:\nhttps://www.cenelec.eu/dyn/www/f?p=104:107:0::::FSP_LANG_ID:25"]
[]
[null,null,"INTEGRATED PUBLIC SERVICE GOVERNANCE"]
[]
[null,"A34","The specification is included in an interoperability agreement established between organisations involved in European public service provision.",null,null,null,"X",null,"No evidences have been found of the specification being included in a formal interoperability agreement between organisations involved in the European public services provision.",null,null,"MIN"]
[]
[null,null,"           LEGAL INTEROPERABILITY"]
[]
[null,"A35","The specification is compliant with a European standardisation regulation (e.g. regulation 1025/2012 on European standardisation).",null,null,null,"✓",null,"PDF/A has been assessed previously by the Netherlands using the Technical scenario which is fully aligned with the European Standardisation Regulation 1025/2012. As the result of the assessment is positive, PDF/A can be considered compliant with the European regulation. \n\nPDF/A in JoinUp: \nhttps://joinup.ec.europa.eu/collection/common-assessment-method-standards-and-specifications-camss/solution/camss-assessment-pdf-a2-scenario-2",null,null,"MIN"]
[]
[null,null,"         ORGANISATIONAL INTEROPERABILITY"]
[]
[null,null,"✓"]
[null,null,"X"]
[null,null,"N/A"]
[null,"A36","The specification is a commonly accepted business process modelling specification.",null,null,null,"N/A",null,"The purpose of PDF/A is not related to the modelling of business processes. Therefore, this criterion is not applicable to the specification. \n\nPDF/A reference:\nhttps://www.iso.org/standard/38920.html\nhttps://www.iso.org/standard/50655.html",null,null,"MIN"]
[]
[null,"A37","The specification defines organisational interoperability aspects (e.g. skills, language, etc.).",null,null,null,"N/A",null,"The purpose of PDF/A is not related to organisational interoperability. Therefore, this criterion is not applicable to the specification.\n\nPDF/A reference:\nhttps://www.iso.org/standard/38920.html\nhttps://www.iso.org/standard/50655.html",null,null,"MIN"]
[]
[null,null,"         SEMANTIC INTEROPERABILITY"]
[]
[null,"A38","The specification defines a cross-sector reusable data model.",null,null,null,"X",null,"PDF/A does not define a cross-sector reusable data model, but defines a file format for representing electronic documents. \n\nPDF/A reference:\nhttps://www.iso.org/standard/38920.html\nhttps://www.iso.org/standard/50655.html"]
[]
[null,"A39","The specification fosters the publication of data as Linked Open Data.",null,null,null,"X",null,"Although PDF/A supports the first level of maturity from the Tim Berners-Lee 5-star schema for the Open data, it is not supporting the main principles for the publication of data as Linked Open Data. \n\nPDF/A reference:\nhttps://www.iso.org/standard/38920.html\nhttps://www.iso.org/standard/50655.html\n\n5-star linked open data:\nhttps://www.w3.org/DesignIssues/LinkedData.html"]
[]
[null,null,"           TECHNICAL INTEROPERABILITY"]
[]
[null," This interoperability layer is covered by criteria A2-A10, corresponding to the core interoperability principle ''Openness'' "]
[]
["                             Please respond to all the criteria before viewing the Results "]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,"✓"]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,"X"]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,"N/A"]

{"sheet":"Assessment_TS","index":9,"n_rows":159,"n_cols":14,"rows_kept":159,"cut":false,"hidden":true,"merged":[[14,3,14,5],[1,5,1,8],[3,5,3,8],[7,5,7,8],[5,5,5,8],[9,5,9,8],[16,3,16,5],[18,3,18,5],[20,3,20,5],[22,3,22,5],[24,3,24,5],[26,3,26,5],[30,3,30,5],[32,3,32,5],[34,3,34,5],[36,3,36,5],[38,3,38,5],[39,3,39,5],[39,6,41,6],[40,3,40,5],[42,3,42,5],[46,3,46,5],[48,3,48,5],[52,3,52,5],[54,3,54,5],[58,3,58,5],[62,3,62,5],[64,3,64,5],[66,3,66,5],[68,3,68,5],[70,3,70,5],[72,3,72,5],[78,3,78,5],[80,3,80,5],[82,3,82,5],[84,3,84,5],[88,3,88,5],[92,3,92,5],[94,3,94,5],[96,3,96,5],[100,3,100,5],[102,3,102,5],[104,3,104,5],[106,3,106,5],[108,3,108,5],[110,3,110,5],[112,3,112,5],[114,3,114,5],[116,3,116,5],[118,3,118,5],[120,3,120,5],[122,3,122,5],[126,3,126,5],[128,3,128,5],[132,3,132,5],[144,3,144,5],[146,0,146,10],[134,3,134,5],[136,3,136,5],[138,3,138,5],[140,3,140,5],[142,3,142,5]]}
[]
[null,null,null,"Date of the Assessment",null,"das"]
[]
[null,null,null,"SDO/SSO"]
[]
[]
[]
[null,null,null,"Title of specification",null,"jk"]
[]
[null,null,null,"Type of specification"]
[]
[null,null,"ID","Criterion",null,null,null,"Answer",null,"Justification"]
[null,null,null," MARKET ACCEPTANCE"]
[]
[null,null,"A1","The technical specification or standard has been used for different implementations by different vendors/suppliers.",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,"MIN"]
[]
[null,null,"A2","The implementation of the technical specification or standard does not hamper interoperability with implementations that are currently based on existing European or international standards.",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,"MIN"]
[]
[null,null,"A3","There are public references (especially policies or in procurement) of the respective specification made by public authorities.",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,"MIN"]
[]
[null,null,"A4","The technical specification or standard has been used in different industries, business sectors and/or functions.",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,"MIN"]
[]
[null,null,"A5","The products that implement the technical specification or standard has a certain or even significant market share of adoption.",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,"MIN"]
[]
[null,null,"A6","The products that implement the technical specification or standard targets a broad spectrum of end-users.",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,"MIN"]
[]
[null,null,"A7","The technical specification or standard has a strong support from at least one interest group."]
[]
[null,null,null," COHERENCE PRINCIPLE"]
[]
[null,null,"A8","The technical specification or standard covers areas different from the areas that are already addressed by technical specifications being under consideration to become European standards.\n(i.e. technical specifications provided by a non-formal standardisation organisation, that is other than CEN, CENELEC or ETSI can be under consideration to become a European standard or alternatively an identified technical specification)",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,"MIN"]
[]
[null,null,"A9    a."," The adoption of new European standards that cover the same areas as the proposed technical specification or standard is not foreseen.",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,"MIN"]
[]
[null,null,"         b. ","There are no existing European standards with market uptake that cover the same areas as the proposed technical specification or standard being assessed.",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,"MIN"]
[]
[null,null,null,"The response to the criteria \"b\" is \"X\" and the existing European standards are becoming obsolete"]
[]
[null,null,"A10","The technical specification or standard is based on one or more relevant international standards."]
[]
[null,null,"A11","The technical specification or standard is listed as recommended by at least one Member State or a European institution.",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,"MIN"]
[]
[null,null,"A12","The technical specification or standard is listed as mandatory by at least one Member State or a European institution.",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,"MIN"]
[]
[null,null,null,"ATTRIBUTES"]
[]
[null,null,"A13","The standards definition/development/setting organisation is a non-profit making organisation."]
[]
[null,null,"A14","Information on the terms and policies for the establishment and operation of the standardisation organisation is publicly available.",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,"MIN"]
[]
[null,null,null,"          OPENNESS"]
[]
[null,null,"A15","Participation in the process of definition of the technical specification is open to all interested parties (e.g. organisations, companies or individuals). "]
[]
[null,null,"A16","The technical specification or standard is reviewed using a formal review process involving all the relevant external stakeholders (e.g. public consultation).",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,"MIN"]
[]
[null,null,null,"          CONSENSUS"]
[]
[null,null,"A17","The standards development/setting organisation approves all the technical specifications and/or standards in a decision making process aiming to reach consensus."]
[]
[null,null,null,"          TRANSPARENCY"]
[]
[null,null,"A18","Relevant documentation of the development and approval process of the specification is archived and identified.",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,"MIN"]
[]
[null,null,"A19","Information on (new) standardisation activities is widely announced through suitable and accessible means.",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,"MIN"]
[]
[null,null,"A20","Relevant stakeholders can formally appeal or raise objections to the development and approval of specifications."]
[]
[null,null,"A21","Information on the standardisation process is publicly available."]
[]
[null,null,"A22","Information on the decision making process for approving the technical specification or standard is publicly available."]
[]
[null,null,"A23","Relevant documentation of the development and approval process of the technical specification or standard is publicly available (e.g. preliminary results, committee meeting notes)."]
[]
[null,null,null,"REQUIREMENTS"]
[]
[null,null,null,"          MAINTENANCE"]
[]
[null,null,"A24","The specification has a defined maintenance and support process."]
[]
[null,null,"A25","The technical specification or standard has a defined maintenance organisation."]
[]
[null,null,"A26","The maintenance organisation for the technical specification or standard has sufficient finances and resources to ensure its freedom from short- to medium-term threats.",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,"MIN"]
[]
[null,null,"A27","The technical specification or standard has a defined policy for version management."]
[]
[null,null,null,"          AVAILABILITY"]
[]
[null,null,"A28","The specification is publicly available for implementation and use on reasonable terms."]
[]
[null,null,null,"          INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY"]
[]
[null,null,"A29  a.","The technical specification or standard is licensed on on a proven/well-motivaded  non-discriminatory basis.",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,"MIN"]
[]
[null,null,"          b. ","The technical specification or standard is licensed on a royalty-free basis."]
[]
[null,null,"A30","The documentation of the IPR for technical specification or standard is publicly available (there is a clear and complete set of licence terms).",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,"MIN"]
[]
[null,null,null,"          RELEVANCE"]
[]
[null,null,"A31  a. ","The technical specification or standard addresses and facilitates interoperability between public administrations.",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,"MIN"]
[]
[null,null,"         b."," The adoption of the technical specification or standard positively impacts on one or several of the following: organisational processes; the environment; the administrative burden; the disability support; cross-border services, public policy objectives and societal needs.",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,"MIN"]
[]
[null,null,"A32","The technical specification or standard addresses, facilitates or is an enabler of eGovernment."]
[]
[null,null,"A33","The functional and non-functional requirements for the use and implementation of the technical specification or standard are clearly defined.",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,"MIN"]
[]
[null,null,"A34","The technical specification or standard is applicable and extensible for implementations in different domains.",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,"MIN"]
[]
[null,null,"A35","The technical specification or standard provides added value compared to alternative technical specifications or standards in the same area of application.",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,"MIN"]
[]
[null,null,"A36","The technical specification or standard is largely compatible with related (not alternative) technical specification or standards in the same area of application.",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,"MIN"]
[]
[null,null,"A37","There is evidence that the adoption of the technical specification or standard makes it easier to migrate between different solutions from different providers.",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,"MIN"]
[]
[null,null,"A38","There is evidence that the adoption of the technical specification or standard positively impacts the financial costs.",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,"MIN"]
[]
[null,null,"A39","There is evidence that the adoption of the technical specification or standard positively impacts any aspect of the security (e.g. data integrity, data authenticity, data transmission or communications, data preservation, cyber threats, penetration, any other aspect related to the security of the information system or interoperability).",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,"MIN"]
[]
[null,null,"A40","There is evidence that the adoption of the technical specification or standard positively impacts privacy."]
[]
[null,null,"A41","The risks related to the adoption of the technical specification or standard are acceptable."]
[]
[null,null,null,"          NEUTRALITY AND STABILITY"]
[]
[null,null,"A42  a.","The technical specification is independent from specific vendor products."]
[]
[null,null,"         b.","The technical specification is independent from specific platforms or technologies."]
[]
[null,null,null,"          QUALITY"]
[]
[null,null,"A43","The specification has sufficient completeness and consistency for the use and development of products and services.",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,"MIN"]
[]
[null,null,"A44","The technical specification or standard is considered mature in the sense that it has overcome most of its initial problems and is considered developed sufficiently (i.e. it fits its purpose).",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,"MIN"]
[]
[null,null,"A45","There are existing or planned mechanisms to assess conformity of the implementations of the technical specification or standard (e.g. conformity tests, certifications).",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,"MIN"]
[]
[null,null,"A46","The technical specification or standard provides implementation guidelines and documentation for the implementation of products.",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,"MIN"]
[]
[null,null,"A47","The technical specification or standard provides an open source reference implementation."]
[]
[null,null,"A48","The technical specification or standard addresses backward compatibility with previous versions."]
[]
[null,null,"A49","The underlying technologies for implementing the technical specification or standard have been clearly defined, are stable and have been tested.",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,"MIN"]
[]
["                             Please respond to all the criteria before viewing the Results "]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[null,null,null,"✓"]
[null,null,null,"X"]
[null,null,null,"N/A"]

{"sheet":"Results","index":10,"n_rows":45,"n_cols":13,"rows_kept":45,"cut":false,"hidden":true,"merged":[[0,0,0,16383],[25,0,25,3],[25,4,25,7],[44,0,44,1022],[45,0,46,1022],[4,4,4,8],[6,4,6,8],[8,4,8,8],[23,0,23,3],[23,4,23,7],[2,4,2,8]]}
["CAMSS Results - MSP Scenario"]
[]
[null,null,"Date of the Assessment",null,"f"]
[]
[null,null,"SDO/SSO",null,"W3C (http://www.w3.org)"]
[]
[null,null,"Title of specification",null,"f"]
[]
[null,null,"Type of specification"]
[]
[null,null,null,null,"Automated Score",null,"CAMSS Assessment Strength",null,"#Favorable",null,"#Unfavorable",null,"#Not Applicable"]
[null,null,"MARKET ACCEPTANCE",null,0,null,0,null,0,null,0,null,0]
[]
[null,null,"COHERENCE PRINCIPLE",null,0,null,0,null,0,null,0,null,0]
[]
[null,null,"ATTRIBUTES",null,0,null,0,null,0,null,0,null,0]
[]
[null,null,"REQUIREMENTS",null,0,null,0,null,0,null,0,null,0]
[]
[]
[null,null,"OVERALL SCORE",null,0,null,0,null,0,null,0,null,0]
[]
[]
["Proposed classification:               "]
[]
["Justification for classification:               "]
[]
[]
[]
[null,null,null,null,"Category","Positive/answered","Negative/answered","Variables represented:"]
[null,null,null,null,"Market acceptance",{"$f":"E12*G12","v":0},{"$f":"G12*(1-E12)","v":0},{"$f":"1-G12","v":1}]
[null,null,null,null,"Coherence principle",{"$f":"E14*G14","v":0},{"$f":"G14*(1-E14)","v":0},{"$f":"1-G14","v":1}]
[null,null,null,null,"Attributes",{"$f":"E16*G16","v":0},{"$f":"G16*(1-E16)","v":0},{"$f":"1-G16","v":1}]
[null,null,null,null,"Requirements",{"$f":"E18*G18","v":0},{"$f":"G18*(1-E18)","v":0},{"$f":"1-G18","v":1}]
[null,null,null,null,"Overall score",{"$f":"E21*G21","v":0},{"$f":"G21*(1-E21)","v":0},{"$f":"1-G21","v":1}]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
["The automated score represents how the technical specification can perform as a standard according to CAMSS. It also represents the percentage of “positive” answers out of all the answers.\n\nThe CAMSS assessment strength represents how accurate the assessment of the technical specification is. It represents the percentage of “positive” And “negative” answers out of all the answers."]

{"sheet":"ResultsTS","index":11,"n_rows":21,"n_cols":13,"rows_kept":21,"cut":false,"hidden":true,"merged":[]}
["          CAMSS Results"]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[null,null,null,null,"Automated Score",null,"CAMSS Assessment Strength",null,"#Favorable",null,"#Unfavorable",null,"#Not Applicable"]
[null,null,"MARKET ACCEPTANCE",null,{"$f":"IF(G12>0,(COUNTIF(Assessment_TS!H15:H27,\"✓\"))/((COUNTIF(Assessment_TS!H15:H27,\"X\"))+(COUNTIF(Assessment_TS!H15:H27,\"✓\"))),0)","v":0},null,{"$f":"(COUNTIF(Assessment_TS!H15:H27,\"✓\")+COUNTIF(Assessment_TS!H15:H27,\"X\"))/7","v":0},null,{"$f":"COUNTIF(Assessment_TS!H15:H27,\"✓\")","v":0},null,{"$f":"COUNTIF(Assessment_TS!H15:H27,\"X\")","v":0},null,{"$f":"COUNTIF(Assessment_TS!H15:H27,\"N/A\")","v":0}]
[]
[null,null,"COHERENCE PRINCIPLE",null,{"$f":"IF(G14>0,(COUNTIF(Assessment_TS!H31:H43,\"✓\"))/((COUNTIF(Assessment_TS!H31:H43,\"X\"))+(COUNTIF(Assessment_TS!H31:H43,\"✓\"))),0)","v":0},null,{"$f":"(COUNTIF(Assessment_TS!H31:H43,\"✓\")+COUNTIF(Assessment_TS!H31:H43,\"X\"))/6","v":0},null,{"$f":"COUNTIF(Assessment_TS!H31:H43,\"✓\")","v":0},null,{"$f":"COUNTIF(Assessment_TS!H31:H43,\"X\")","v":0},null,{"$f":"COUNTIF(Assessment_TS!H31:H43,\"N/A\")","v":0}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"(COUNTIF(Assessment_TS!H31:H43,\"✓\")+COUNTIF(Assessment_TS!H31:H43,\"X\"))/6","v":0}]
[null,null,"ATTRIBUTES",null,{"$f":"IF(G16>0,(COUNTIF(Assessment_TS!H47:H73,\"✓\"))/((COUNTIF(Assessment_TS!H47:H73,\"X\"))+(COUNTIF(Assessment_TS!H47:H73,\"✓\"))),0)","v":0},null,{"$f":"(COUNTIF(Assessment_TS!H47:H73,\"✓\")+COUNTIF(Assessment_TS!H47:H73,\"X\"))/11","v":0},null,{"$f":"COUNTIF(Assessment_TS!H47:H73,\"✓\")","v":0},null,{"$f":"COUNTIF(Assessment_TS!H47:H73,\"X\")","v":0},null,{"$f":"COUNTIF(Assessment_TS!H47:H73,\"N/A\")","v":0}]
[]
[null,null,"REQUIREMENTS",null,{"$f":"IF(G18>0,(COUNTIF(Assessment_TS!H79:H145,\"✓\"))/((COUNTIF(Assessment_TS!H79:H145,\"X\"))+(COUNTIF(Assessment_TS!H79:H145,\"✓\"))),0)","v":0},null,{"$f":"(COUNTIF(Assessment_TS!H79:H145,\"✓\")+COUNTIF(Assessment_TS!H79:H145,\"X\"))/29","v":0},null,{"$f":"COUNTIF(Assessment_TS!H79:H145,\"✓\")","v":0},null,{"$f":"COUNTIF(Assessment_TS!H79:H145,\"X\")","v":0},null,{"$f":"COUNTIF(Assessment_TS!H79:H145,\"N/A\")","v":0}]
[]
[]
[null,null,"OVERALL SCORE",null,{"$f":"IF(G21>0,(COUNTIF(Assessment_TS!H15:H145,\"✓\"))/((COUNTIF(Assessment_TS!H15:H145,\"X\"))+(COUNTIF(Assessment_TS!H15:H145,\"✓\"))),0)","v":0},null,{"$f":"(COUNTIF(Assessment_TS!H15:H145,\"✓\")+COUNTIF(Assessment_TS!H15:H145,\"X\"))/53","v":0},null,{"$f":"SUM(I12:I18)","v":0},null,{"$f":"SUM(K12:K18)","v":0},null,{"$f":"SUM(M12:M18)","v":0}]

{"sheet":"ResultsMSP","index":12,"n_rows":21,"n_cols":13,"rows_kept":21,"cut":false,"hidden":true,"merged":[]}
["          CAMSS Results"]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[null,null,null,null,"Automated Score",null,"CAMSS Assessment Strength",null,"#Favorable",null,"#Unfavorable",null,"#Not Applicable"]
[null,null,"MARKET ACCEPTANCE",null,{"$f":"IF(G12>0,SUM(COUNTIF(Assessment_MSP!I16,\"Yes\"),COUNTIF(Assessment_MSP!I18,\"No\"),COUNTIF(Assessment_MSP!I20,\"Yes\")) / (COUNTIF(Assessment_MSP!I16:I20,\"Yes\")+COUNTIF(Assessment_MSP!I16:I20,\"No\")),0)","v":0},null,{"$f":"(COUNTIF(Assessment_MSP!I16:I20,\"Yes\")+COUNTIF(Assessment_MSP!I16:I20,\"No\"))/3","v":0},null,{"$f":"SUM(COUNTIF(Assessment_MSP!I16, \"Yes\"),COUNTIF(Assessment_MSP!I18, \"No\"),COUNTIF(Assessment_MSP!I20, \"Yes\"))","v":0},null,{"$f":"SUM(COUNTIF(Assessment_MSP!I16, \"No\"),COUNTIF(Assessment_MSP!I18, \"Yes\"),COUNTIF(Assessment_MSP!I20, \"No\"))","v":0},null,{"$f":"(COUNTIF(Assessment_MSP!I16:I20,\"N/A\"))","v":0}]
[]
[null,null,"COHERENCE PRINCIPLE",null,{"$f":"IF(G14>0,SUM(COUNTIF(Assessment_MSP!I24,\"Yes\"),COUNTIF(Assessment_MSP!I26:I28,\"No\"),COUNTIF(Assessment_MSP!I30,\"Yes\")) / (COUNTIF(Assessment_MSP!I24:I30,\"Yes\") + COUNTIF(Assessment_MSP!I24:I30,\"No\")),0%)","v":0},null,{"$f":"(COUNTIF(Assessment_MSP!I24:I30,\"Yes\")+COUNTIF(Assessment_MSP!I24:I30,\"No\"))/3","v":0},null,{"$f":"SUM(COUNTIF(Assessment_MSP!I24, \"Yes\"),COUNTIF(Assessment_MSP!I26:I28, \"No\"),COUNTIF(Assessment_MSP!I30,\"Yes\"))","v":0},null,{"$f":"SUM(COUNTIF(Assessment_MSP!I24, \"No\"),COUNTIF(Assessment_MSP!I26:I28, \"Yes\"),COUNTIF(Assessment_MSP!I30,\"No\"))","v":0},null,{"$f":"(COUNTIF(Assessment_MSP!I24:I30,\"N/A\"))","v":0}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"(COUNTIF(Assessment_MSP!I24:I30,\"Yes\")+COUNTIF(Assessment_MSP!I24:I30,\"No\"))/4","v":0}]
[null,null,"ATTRIBUTES",null,{"$f":"IF(G16>0,SUM(COUNTIF(Assessment_MSP!I34:I50,\"Yes\")) / ( COUNTIF(Assessment_MSP!I34:I50,\"Yes\") + COUNTIF(Assessment_MSP!I34:I50,\"No\")),0%)","v":0},null,{"$f":"(COUNTIF(Assessment_MSP!I34:I50,\"Yes\") + COUNTIF(Assessment_MSP!I34:I50,\"No\"))/6","v":0},null,{"$f":"(COUNTIF(Assessment_MSP!I34:I50,\"Yes\"))","v":0},null,{"$f":"(COUNTIF(Assessment_MSP!I34:I50,\"No\"))","v":0},null,{"$f":"(COUNTIF(Assessment_MSP!I34:I50,\"N/A\"))","v":0}]
[]
[null,null,"REQUIREMENTS",null,{"$f":"IF(G18>0,SUM(COUNTIF(Assessment_MSP!I56:I82,\"Yes\")) / ( COUNTIF(Assessment_MSP!I56:I82,\"Yes\") + COUNTIF(Assessment_MSP!I56:I82,\"No\")),0%)","v":0},null,{"$f":"(COUNTIF(Assessment_MSP!I56:I82,\"Yes\") + COUNTIF(Assessment_MSP!I56:I82,\"No\"))/9","v":0},null,{"$f":"(COUNTIF(Assessment_MSP!I56:I82,\"Yes\"))","v":0},null,{"$f":"(COUNTIF(Assessment_MSP!I56:I82,\"No\"))","v":0},null,{"$f":"(COUNTIF(Assessment_MSP!I56:I82,\"N/A\"))","v":0}]
[]
[]
[null,null,"OVERALL SCORE",null,{"$f":"SUM(E12:E18)/4","v":0},null,{"$f":"SUM(G12:G18)/4","v":0},null,{"$f":"SUM(I12:I18)","v":0},null,{"$f":"SUM(K12:K18)","v":0},null,{"$f":"SUM(M12:M18)","v":0}]

{"sheet":"Results ","index":13,"n_rows":102,"n_cols":16,"rows_kept":102,"cut":false,"hidden":false,"merged":[[66,15,67,15],[64,2,64,12],[66,17,67,17],[0,0,0,13],[101,2,101,12],[2,4,2,11],[4,4,4,11],[6,4,6,11],[8,4,8,11],[66,2,67,2],[66,4,67,4],[66,12,67,12],[66,10,67,10],[66,8,67,8],[66,6,67,6]]}
["CAMSS Results - EIF Scenario"]
[]
[null,null,"  Date of the Assessment",null,"2020-08-31"]
[]
[null,null,"  SDO/SSO"]
[]
[null,null,"Interoperability specification",null,"Portable Document Format/A (PDF/A)"]
[]
[null,null,"Interoperability specification type",null,"International Standard"]
[]
[]
[null,null,null,null,"Automated Score",null,"Assessment Strength",null,"#Favorable",null,"#Unfavorable",null,"#Not \nApplicable"]
[]
[]
[null,null,"SUBSIDIARITY AND PROPORTIONALITY",null,{"$f":"IF(G15>0,(COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G18,\"✓\"))/((COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G18,\"X\"))+(COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G18,\"✓\"))),0)","v":1},null,{"$f":"(COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G18,\"✓\")+COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G18,\"X\"))/1","v":1},null,{"$f":"COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G18,\"✓\")","v":1},null,{"$f":"COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G18,\"X\")","v":0},null,{"$f":"COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G18,\"N/A\")","v":0}]
[]
[null,null,"PRINCIPLE SETTING THE CONTEXT FOR EU ACTIONS ON INTEROPERABILITY",null,{"$f":"IF(G17>0,(COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G18,\"✓\"))/((COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G18,\"X\"))+(COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G18,\"✓\"))),0)","v":1},null,{"$f":"(COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G18,\"✓\")+COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G18,\"X\"))/1","v":1},null,{"$f":"COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G18,\"✓\")","v":1},null,{"$f":"COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G18,\"X\")","v":0},null,{"$f":"COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G18,\"N/A\")","v":0}]
[]
[]
[null,null,"OPENNESS",null,{"$f":"IF(G20>0,(COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G24:G42,\"✓\"))/((COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G24:G42,\"X\"))+(COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G24:G42,\"✓\"))),0)","v":0.5},null,{"$f":"(COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G24:G42,\"✓\")+COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G24:G42,\"X\"))/10","v":1},null,{"$f":"COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G24:G42,\"✓\")","v":5},null,{"$f":"COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G24:G42,\"X\")","v":5},null,{"$f":"COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G24:G42,\"N/A\")","v":0}]
[]
[null,null,"TRANSPARENCY",null,{"$f":"IF(G22>0,(COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G46:G50,\"✓\"))/((COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G46:G50,\"X\"))+(COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G46:G50,\"✓\"))),0)","v":1},null,{"$f":"(COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G46:G50,\"✓\")+COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G46:G50,\"X\"))/3","v":0.66666666666666663},null,{"$f":"COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G46:G50,\"✓\")","v":2},null,{"$f":"COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G46:G50,\"X\")","v":0},null,{"$f":"COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G46:G50,\"N/A\")","v":1}]
[]
[null,null,"REUSABILITY",null,{"$f":"IF(G24>0,(COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G54:G58,\"✓\"))/((COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G54:G58,\"X\"))+(COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G54:G58,\"✓\"))),0)","v":0.33333333333333331},null,{"$f":"(COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G54:G58,\"✓\")+COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G54:G58,\"X\"))/3","v":1},null,{"$f":"COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G54:G58,\"✓\")","v":1},null,{"$f":"COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G54:G58,\"X\")","v":2},null,{"$f":"COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G54:G56,\"N/A\")","v":0}]
[]
[null,null,"TECHNOLOGICAL NEUTRALITY AND DATA PORTABILITY",null,{"$f":"IF(G26>0,(COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G62:G66,\"✓\"))/((COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G62:G66,\"X\"))+(COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G62:G66,\"✓\"))),0)","v":1},null,{"$f":"(COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G62:G66,\"✓\")+COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G62:G66,\"X\"))/3","v":1},null,{"$f":"COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G62:G66,\"✓\")","v":3},null,{"$f":"COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G62:G66,\"X\")","v":0},null,{"$f":"COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G62:G66,\"N/A\")","v":0},null,null,1]
[]
[null,null," CORE INTEROPERABILITY PRINCIPLES",null,{"$f":"IF(G28>0,(COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G24:G66,\"✓\"))/((COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G24:G66,\"X\"))+(COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G24:G66,\"✓\"))),0)","v":0.61111111111111116},null,{"$f":"(COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G24:G66,\"✓\")+COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G24:G66,\"X\"))/19","v":0.94736842105263153},null,{"$f":"SUM(I20,I22,I24,I26)","v":11},null,{"$f":"SUM(K20,K22,K24,K26)","v":7},null,{"$f":"SUM(M20,M22,M24,M26)","v":1}]
[]
[]
[null,null,"USER-CENTRICITY",null,{"$f":"IF(G31>0,(COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G72,\"✓\"))/((COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G72,\"X\"))+(COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G72,\"✓\"))),0)","v":0},null,{"$f":"(COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G72,\"✓\")+COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G72,\"X\"))/1","v":0},null,{"$f":"COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G72,\"✓\")","v":0},null,{"$f":"COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G72,\"X\")","v":0},null,{"$f":"COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G72,\"N/A\")","v":1}]
[]
[null,null,"INCLUSION AND ACCESSIBILITY",null,{"$f":"IF(G33>0,(COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G76,\"✓\"))/((COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G76,\"X\"))+(COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G76,\"✓\"))),0)","v":0},null,{"$f":"(COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G76,\"✓\")+COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G76,\"X\"))/1","v":0},null,{"$f":"COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G76,\"✓\")","v":0},null,{"$f":"COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G76,\"X\")","v":0},null,{"$f":"COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G76,\"N/A\")","v":1}]
[]
[null,null,"SECURITY AND PRIVACY",null,{"$f":"IF(G35>0,(COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G80,\"✓\"))/((COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G80,\"X\"))+(COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G80,\"✓\"))),0)","v":1},null,{"$f":"(COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G80,\"✓\")+COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G80,\"X\"))/1","v":1},null,{"$f":"COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G80,\"✓\")","v":1},null,{"$f":"COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G80,\"X\")","v":0},null,{"$f":"COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G80,\"N/A\")","v":0}]
[]
[null,null,"MULTILINGUALISM",null,{"$f":"IF(G37>0,(COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G84,\"✓\"))/((COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G84,\"X\"))+(COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G84,\"✓\"))),0)","v":0},null,{"$f":"(COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G84,\"✓\")+COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G84,\"X\"))/1","v":0},null,{"$f":"COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G84,\"✓\")","v":0},null,{"$f":"COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G84,\"X\")","v":0},null,{"$f":"COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G84,\"N/A\")","v":1}]
[]
[null,null,"PRINCIPLES RELATED TO GENERIC USER NEEDS AND EXPECTATIONS",null,{"$f":"IF(G39>0,(COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G72:G84,\"✓\"))/((COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G72:G84,\"X\"))+(COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G72:G84,\"✓\"))),0)","v":1},null,{"$f":"(COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G72:G84,\"✓\")+COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G72:G84,\"X\"))/4","v":0.25},null,{"$f":"SUM(I31:I37)","v":1},null,{"$f":"SUM(K31:K37)","v":0},null,{"$f":"SUM(M31:M37)","v":3},null,null,1]
[]
[]
[null,null,"ADMINISTRATIVE SIMPLIFICATION",null,{"$f":"IF(G42>0,(COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G90,\"✓\"))/((COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G90,\"X\"))+(COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G90,\"✓\"))),0)","v":1},null,{"$f":"(COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G90,\"✓\")+COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G90,\"X\"))/1","v":1},null,{"$f":"COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G90,\"✓\")","v":1},null,{"$f":"COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G90,\"X\")","v":0},null,{"$f":"COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G90,\"N/A\")","v":0}]
[]
[null,null,"PRESERVATION OF INFORMATION",null,{"$f":"IF(G44>0,(COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G94,\"✓\"))/((COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G94,\"X\"))+(COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G94,\"✓\"))),0)","v":1},null,{"$f":"(COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G94,\"✓\")+COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G94,\"X\"))/1","v":1},null,{"$f":"COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G94,\"✓\")","v":1},null,{"$f":"COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G94,\"X\")","v":0},null,{"$f":"COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G94,\"N/A\")","v":0}]
[]
[null,null,"ASSESSMENT OF EFFECTIVENESS AND EFFICIENCY",null,{"$f":"IF(G46>0,(COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G98,\"✓\"))/((COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G98,\"X\"))+(COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G98,\"✓\"))),0)","v":0},null,{"$f":"(COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G98,\"✓\")+COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G98,\"X\"))/1","v":1},null,{"$f":"COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G98,\"✓\")","v":0},null,{"$f":"COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G98,\"X\")","v":1},null,{"$f":"COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G98,\"N/A\")","v":0}]
[]
[null,null,"FOUNDATION PRINCIPLES FOR COOPERATION AMONG PUBLIC ADMINISTRATIONS",null,{"$f":"IF(G48>0,(COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G90:G98,\"✓\"))/((COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G90:G98,\"X\"))+(COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G90:G98,\"✓\"))),0)","v":0.66666666666666663},null,{"$f":"(COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G90:G98,\"✓\")+COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G90:G98,\"X\"))/3","v":1},null,{"$f":"SUM(I42:I46)","v":2},null,{"$f":"SUM(K42:K46)","v":1},null,{"$f":"SUM(M42:M46)","v":0},null,null,1]
[]
[]
[null,null,"INTEROPERABILITY GOVERNANCE",null,{"$f":"IF(G51>0,(COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G104:G114,\"✓\"))/((COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G104:G114,\"X\"))+(COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G104:G114,\"✓\"))),0)","v":0.66666666666666663},null,{"$f":"(COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G104:G114,\"✓\")+COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G104:G114,\"X\"))/6","v":1},null,{"$f":"COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G104:G114,\"✓\")","v":4},null,{"$f":"COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G104:G114,\"X\")","v":2},null,{"$f":"COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G104:G114,\"N/A\")","v":0}]
[]
[null,null,"INTEGRATED PUBLIC SERVICE GOVERNANCE",null,{"$f":"IF(G53>0,(COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G118,\"✓\"))/((COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G118,\"X\"))+(COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G118,\"✓\"))),0)","v":0},null,{"$f":"(COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G118,\"✓\")+COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G118,\"X\"))/1","v":1},null,{"$f":"COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G118,\"✓\")","v":0},null,{"$f":"COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G118,\"X\")","v":1},null,{"$f":"COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G118,\"N/A\")","v":0}]
[]
[null,null,"LEGAL INTEROPERABILITY",null,{"$f":"IF(G55>0,(COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G122,\"✓\"))/((COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G122,\"X\"))+(COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G122,\"✓\"))),0)","v":1},null,{"$f":"(COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G122,\"✓\")+COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G122,\"X\"))/1","v":1},null,{"$f":"COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G122,\"✓\")","v":1},null,{"$f":"COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G122,\"X\")","v":0},null,{"$f":"COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G122,\"N/A\")","v":0}]
[]
[null,null,"ORGANISATIONAL INTEROPERABILITY",null,{"$f":"IF(G57>0,(COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G129:G131,\"✓\"))/((COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G129:G131,\"X\"))+(COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G129:G131,\"✓\"))),0)","v":0},null,{"$f":"(COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G129:G131,\"✓\")+COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G129:G131,\"X\"))/2","v":0},null,{"$f":"COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G129:G131,\"✓\")","v":0},null,{"$f":"COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G129:G131,\"X\")","v":0},null,{"$f":"COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G129:G131,\"N/A\")","v":2},null,null,1]
[]
[null,null,"SEMANTIC INTEROPERABILITY",null,{"$f":"IF(G59>0,(COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G135:G137,\"✓\"))/((COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G135:G137,\"X\"))+(COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G135:G137,\"✓\"))),0)","v":0},null,{"$f":"(COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G135:G137,\"✓\")+COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G135:G137,\"X\"))/2","v":1},null,{"$f":"COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G135:G137,\"✓\")","v":0},null,{"$f":"COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G135:G137,\"X\")","v":2},null,{"$f":"COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G135:G137,\"N/A\")","v":0}]
[]
[null,null,"TECHNICAL INTEROPERABILITY*",null,{"$f":"IF(G61>0,(COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G24:G42,\"✓\"))/((COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G24:G42,\"X\"))+(COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G24:G42,\"✓\"))),0)","v":0.5},null,{"$f":"(COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G24:G42,\"✓\")+COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G24:G42,\"X\"))/10","v":1}]
[]
[null,null,"INTEROPERABILITY LAYERS",null,{"$f":"IF(G63>0,((COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G104:G137,\"✓\"))+(COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G24:G42,\"✓\")))/(((COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G104:G137,\"X\"))+(COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G104:G137,\"✓\")))+((COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G24:G42,\"X\"))+(COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G24:G42,\"✓\")))),0)","v":0.5},null,{"$f":"(((COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G104:G137,\"X\"))+(COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G104:G137,\"✓\")))+((COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G24:G42,\"X\"))+(COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G24:G42,\"✓\"))))/22","v":0.90909090909090906},null,{"$f":"SUM(I51:I59,I20)","v":10},null,{"$f":"SUM(K51:K59,K20)","v":10},null,{"$f":"SUM(M51:M59,M20)","v":2},null,null,1]
[]
[null,null,"*The technical interoperability layer is covered by the criteria corresponding to the core interoperability principle ''Openness''. "]
[]
[null,null,"OVERALL SCORE",null,{"$f":"IF(G67>0,(COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G18:G137,\"✓\"))/((COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G18:G137,\"X\"))+(COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G18:G137,\"✓\"))),0)","v":0.60606060606060608},null,{"$f":"(COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G18:G137,\"✓\")+COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G18:G137,\"X\"))/39","v":0.84615384615384615},null,{"$f":"COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G18:G137,\"✓\")","v":20},null,{"$f":"COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G18:G137,\"X\")","v":13},null,{"$f":"COUNTIF(Assessment_EIF!G18:G137,\"N/A\")","v":6},null,null,1]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[null,null,"The automated score is the percentage of “favorable” answers out of all the answers. \nThe CAMSS assessment strength is the percentage of \"favorable\" and \"unfavorable\" answers out of all the answers. "]

{"sheet":"ResultsODSAT","index":14,"n_rows":0,"n_cols":0,"rows_kept":0,"cut":false,"hidden":true,"merged":[]}